Mitochondrial DNA as a potential tool for early cancer detection

Prostate cancer (PCa) is a transformation of the secretory epithelial cells lining the ductal network of the prostate gland. In the USA alone, over 230,000 men developed PCa in 2005 (Facts and Figures, American Cancer Society, 2005). The way in which human prostate epithelial cells metabolise citrate is strikingly different from other soft tissues. The peripheral zone of the prostate gland, which accounts for the majority of prostate tumours, has a uniquely different metabolism. For this reason, the metabolic characteristics of this tissue are central to mtDNA damage and its role in PCa. Unlike the central zone, the peripheral zone cells accumulate very high levels of zinc, due in part to the activity of a zinc transporter [10, 11]. Zinc levels in these cells are about ten-fold higher than in other cell types. The high zinc levels in the mitochondria inhibit an initial Krebs cycle enzyme, aconitase, thereby preventing the isomerisation of citrate to isocitrate, which is required for the complete metabolism of citrate. This precludes the movement of NADH and FADH₂ from the Krebs cycle into the electron transport chain. Interestingly, during the pathway of malignant transformation, zinc levels drop and the Krebs cycle becomes active. Peripheral zone prostate cells then become energy efficient, consuming substantial amounts of oxygen, in contrast to many other tumours that are energy inefficient. The increased functional capacity of the Krebs cycle in these transforming cells might be responsible for the up-regulation of enzymes involved in energy-generating pathways such as β-oxidation [12, 13]. Hypothetically, this raises the intriguing possibility of high reactive oxygen species (ROS) production, which can cause significant oxidative damage to the mitochondrial genome. There may be a sudden increase, or burst, of ROS, which heavily damage mtDNA, perhaps overwhelming any operational mtDNA repair mechanisms. Proteomics analysis reveals altered expression of nuclear-encoded complex IV subunits in pre-malignant prostate epithelial cells [14]. Such protein changes could affect the functions of this complex, resulting in defective oxidative phosphorylation. Thus, a state of reversed electron flow in the redox series can arise, leading to elevated ROS production. Under normal circumstances, elevated ROS induces the activity of antioxidant scavengers such as glutathione peroxidase. In support of the pivotal role of ROS in PCa development, however, is the early silencing of the gene encoding glutathione S-transferase-π (GSTP1) via hypermethylation of its promoter in PCa [15] and the presence of high levels of hydrogen peroxide in PCa cells compared with normal prostate epithelial cells [16].

An early metabolic switch which may lead to increased ROS production in association with a loss of antioxidant mechanisms should culminate in accelerated mtDNA mutations in PCa. Not surprisingly then, the few reports of mtDNA mutations in PCa indicate a state of hypermutagenesis [17–20]. The first study of mtDNA mutations in PCa examined large mtDNA deletions by gel electrophoresis and observed a positive correlation between deletion frequency and advancing age [21]. Four other studies involved sequencing regions of the mtDNA genome. The D-loop and adjacent regions were examined in three studies [17–19]. In these studies, a total of 34 substitutions and four small insertions and deletions were detected. In addition, the following mutations were detected in coding genes flanking the D-loop: one mutation each in the 16S ribosomal RNA gene (16SrRNA) and the transfer RNA leucine gene (tRNA ^leu ); three in ND4; and four each in ND1, ND5 and CYTB. The fifth and most recent study of mtDNA alterations in PCa focused on the COI gene. This study involved a large population sample from which a total of 21 unique nucleotide changes were detected in PCa. Two mutations, G6261A (six individuals) and A6663G (five individuals) seem to be mutation hot spots in PCa.

MtDNA alterations in the prostate gland may have significant utility for early PCa detection, given the uniqueness of this molecule and the mode of occurrence of mtDNA mutations in the prostate. The metabolic and mtDNA alterations in the prostate are likely to be early events in PCa development, since they are observed in pre-malignant histological benign-appearing glands. Prostate epithelial cells are present in prostate fluids such as prostate massage fluid, and the high copy number of mitochondrial genomes coupled with the accelerated mtDNA mutations in PCa and, in some instances, the homoplasmic nature of the mutations, should offer a detection advantage over nuclear genome alterations in biofluids [19, 22].

Much like prostate cancer, breast cancer is also a transformation of the epithelial secretory cells lining the mammary ducts. Breast cancer was diagnosed in nearly 213,000 women in the USA in 2005 (Facts and Figures, American Cancer Society, 2005). More than ten papers describing altered mtDNA in human breast tumour tissue have been published in the two years since Carew and Huang published their comprehensive review of mtDNA defects in cancer [4]. There have been a variety of mtDNA alterations found in breast tumour tissue since the first report published by Bianchi et al. about ten years ago [23]. While the precise frequency, region of the mtDNA genome characterised and nature of mtDNA mutations associated with breast tumour tissue varies in each report, there is compelling evidence that somatic mutations in mtDNA represent informative biomarkers for detecting disease. A number of investigators successfully obtained sufficient quantities of DNA from nipple aspirate fluid (NAF) and from ductal lavage to perform mtDNA analysis, thus providing the possibility of non-invasive methods using mtDNA as a sensitive means to detect breast cancer.

Rates of somatic mtDNA mutations in breast cancer range from that reported in a 2002 study by Tan et al.[24] (74 per cent; 14/19 tested) to the recent results of Tan et al.[25] looking at a much larger sample size, with a reported rate of 45 per cent heteroplasmy. Zhu et al. found mutated mtDNA in 93 per cent of breast cancer samples (14 of 15 tested), with the frequency of mutations higher in the D-loop than in other loci tested (1.5 per cent versus 0.18 per cent) [26]. In addition, Zhu et al. tested whether NAF provided mtDNA that carried mutations found in the patient's tumour and found that 40 per cent of the NAF samples contained some of the mutations observed in the patient's tumour mtDNA. Rosson and Keshgegian found mtDNA mutations in 15 of 15 tumour samples micro-dissected by laser capture microscopy from 15 different patients [27]. The number of mutations found in the D-loop ranged from one to 15 relative to an adjacent normal tissue control mtDNA sequence. As others have found that adjacent normal control tissue does not necessarily represent the 'wild-type' and frequently harbours tumour-type mtDNA mutations, the results of Rosson and Keshgegian may under-report the true number of mutations in the samples studied [27]. Zhu et al. found a 4,576 bp deletion in mtDNA to be a good marker for breast cancer, in that it was present 77 per cent of the time in 39 tumours and 0 per cent in true normal samples [28]. Interestingly, 13 per cent of the histologically 'normal' adjacent tumour tissue samples showed the 4,576 bp deletion, suggesting that, while the histology appears normal, the genotype is moving towards the tumour state. Dani et al. found a different mtDNA deletion--the 4,977 base pair deletion--in 24 per cent of breast tumours but concluded that this resulted from contaminating adjacent tissue and, in fact, stated that tumours are essentially free of the 4,977 base pair deletion [29]. This is in contrast to Zhu et al., who found the 4,977 base pair deletions in breast tumours (18/39, 46 per cent) to occur at a rate higher than in adjacent normal tissue (13/39, 33 per cent) and normal tissue (6/23, 26 per cent) [28]. The explanation for this apparent discrepancy remains to be determined. Isaacs et al. investigated the D310 [30] mtDNA marker in conjunction with loss of heterozygosity from 14 women of known BRCA1 status and found three of nine mtDNA mutations in BRCA1 carriers. They further demonstrated that the same DNA typing results could be obtained from NAF as well as ductal lavage samples [31]. D310 is of particular note because in some groups this nucleotide is a T as opposed to a C. In a similar study, Parrella et al. looked at the D310 mtDNA marker and found that three of 20 mtDNA mutations (15 per cent) had mutated in the tumour compared with the normal tissue [32]. They reported that, comparing tumour with blood mtDNA, 61 per cent of the tumours had mtDNA mutations.

Colorectal cancer affected over 145,000 people in the USA alone in 2005 (Cancer Facts and Figures 2005). More than 95 per cent of colorectal cancers are adenocarcinomas which develop from adenomatous polyps (adenomas); however, only a small portion of these lesions progress to invasive cancer (1-10 per cent). Current diagnostic tools include the faecal occult blood test and the multitarget assay panel (MTAP), which looks for mutations associated with the nuclear genome (Jani National Cancer Institute). Deficiencies in DNA repair and a higher mutation rate in the mitochondria result in the accumulation of mutations that may provide a means for the early detection of human colorectal lesions (polyps or cancer) and may increase the utility of the MTAP test. For those at risk (familial or age related), a colonoscopy is the screening method of choice.

Previous research examining the D-loop or non-coding region (NCR), or performing complete sequencing of the mitochondrial genome in colorectal tumours, found that the majority of the somatic mutations were homoplasmic transitions and single bp insertions or deletions, and that there were few large-scale deletions [33–36]. Habano et al. were among the first to report microsatellite instability in 20/45 colorectal cancer samples in the NCR of the mitochondrial genome [37]. The nature of these alterations is consistent with ROS damage and low levels of DNA repair. Furthermore, somatic mutations and altered gene expression were found in: 12SrRNA; 16SrRNA; the NADH ubiquinone oxidoreductase subunit genes ND1, ND4, ND5; the cytochrome oxidase subunit genes COXI, COXII, COXIII; and the cytochrome gene CYTB. Recently, Guleng et al. reported no mutations in the ND1 and ND5 genes [38]. Aikhionbare et al. investigated the mitochondrial genome with restriction analyses, followed by the sequencing of length variants for three histological subtypes of colorectal adenomas, in association with tumour and matched surrounding normal tissues [36]. Thirty-eight sequence variants for the precursor and cancerous lesions were identified. This method does not detect single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that do not create a restriction site, however, meaning that the actual number of alterations could be higher. Interestingly, none of their 38 sequence variants matched the somatic mutations cited in previous reviews,[4, 5] but the regions of mitochondrial instability were similar. The results of Aikhionbare et al. indicate a high prevalence of mutations in tumour tissue, with much lower numbers in pre-cancerous lesions and no mutations in the surrounding normal tissue. A progressive pattern is indicated.

The incidence of skin cancer has steadily increased over the past decade, with more than 1 million new cases currently being diagnosed each year in the USA and 65,000 in the UK (figure provided by Cancer Research UK). Apart from malignant melanoma, non-melanoma skin cancer (NMSC) accounts for around 90 per cent of skin cancers and consists of basal cell and squamous cell carcinomas (BCC and SCC, respectively). BCCs are the most common form of NMSC and arise predominantly from the basal keratinocytes of the epidermis but also from cells in hair follicles and sebaceous glands. They are locally invasive but rarely metastasise. SCCs are also derived from basal keratinocytes; however, in contrast to BCCs, SCCs may metastasise. Cutaneous malignant melanoma is a malignant tumour of the melanocytes, usually arising in the epidermis, and is the most lethal of the skin cancers.

The cause of the great majority of skin cancers, including malignant melanoma, in pale-skinned individuals is a combination of the DNA-damaging effects of ultraviolet radiation (UVR) in sunlight and the characteristics that determine the response of the body to that radiation. In human skin, mtDNA, rather than nuclear DNA, is a useful biomarker of UV-induced DNA damage [39–41]. Moreover, within the field of skin cancer research, there is an additional advantage of using mtDNA, namely that there is no evidence of nuclear excision for the repair of DNA photoproducts (e.g. cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers) in mtDNA [42–45]. Together, these factors lead to accumulation of photodamage in skin mtDNA without compromising cell function.

These aspects, together with the fact that UVR is important in the development of skin cancer and has been shown to induce mtDNA damage in human skin,[40, 46] led to the first detailed study of mtDNA damage in human NMSC [47]. This work showed clear differences in the distribution of deletions between the tumour and the histologically normal perilesional skin.

In the literature, there are three recent studies that have investigated the relationship between mtDNA and cutaneous malignant melanoma [48–50]. Two of the three studies [48, 49] have screened for mtDNA mutations (but not deletions or duplications) in the NCR alone, which constitutes less than 7 per cent of the mitochondrial genome. The study by Takeuchi et al.[48] found that the somatic mutations in the D-loop region of tumour and paired plasma did not correlate with the clinicopathological characteristics. The study by Deichmann et al.[49] found microsatellite instability (mtMSI) of mtDNA C_n tracts in the primary tumours. The larger patient study by Poetsch et al.[50] investigated the D-loop, as well as looking for the 4,977 bp common deletion in 61 primary malignant melanomas and in neighbouring normal skin tissue. Point mutations were a rare feature, whereas mtDNA instability in the D-loop (mtMSI) was found in 13 per cent of primary nodular tumours and in 20 per cent of metastases. The 4,977 bp common deletion was demonstrated in 10 per cent of melanomas.

The increased frequency of the mtDNA deletions and point mutations in human skin with increasing UVR exposure provides a measure of cumulative UV exposure in human skin. Together with the mtDNA damage identified in the skin cancer studies, this may in turn provide an early detection tool for skin cancer development, as well as providing a method for monitoring the long-term safety of clinical UV phototherapy regimens, since the risk of skin cancer must be minimised. Interestingly, mtDNA D-loop alterations can be detected in blood and may therefore potentially act as a circulating DNA melanoma marker [48]. In addition, C_n tract alterations occurred in two out of nine primary melanomas with subsequent metastasis, whereas none of the 20 nonmetastasising cutaneous melanomas were affected [49]. These somatic changes may reflect genomic imbalance during tumour progression and may therefore be useful for the assessment of patients' prognosis with a simple, small punch biopsy. Early diagnosis of skin cancer is particularly desirable because of the successful methods of treatment which are currently available to the dermatologist.

Lung cancer comprises a spectrum of diseases and is the leading cause of cancer-related deaths among men and women in developed countries. There are two major classifications of lung cancer, small cell (SCLC) and non-small cell (NSCLC) carcinoma. SCLC is divided into three subtypes: small cell, mixed small cell/large cell and combined small cell carcinoma (small cell lung cancer combined with neoplastic squamous and/or glandular components). Although SCLC is more responsive to chemotherapy and radiation, it is usually well spread at primary diagnosis, making it difficult to treat successfully. Even with treatment, the overall survival rate at five years is 5-10 per cent. NSCLC is a conglomeration of at least three distinct pathohistologies: squamous cell carcinoma, adenocarcinoma and large cell carcinoma. Localised surgical resection is the standard treatment; however, all newly diagnosed NSCLC patients are possible candidates for treatment studies.

Currently, there are more than 170,000 single lung nodules 'discovered' in patients each year in the USA alone. (Facts and Figures, American Cancer Society, 2005) Most of these are found during routine lung X-rays, meaning that detection techniques are really based on chance. Confirmation of diagnosis includes a follow-up biopsy, computed tomography (CT) scan or 'watchful waiting', where X-ray or CT scans are repeated at intervals to assess changes in the lesion. The 'gold standard' is surgical resection; however, 60 per cent of lung nodules are benign, hence, over half of the patients will undergo unnecessary surgery. From a diagnostic perspective, there are promising molecular tools, such as those detecting telomerase activity in tumour cells.

Improvement in the diagnostic strategy for lung cancer is a critical need in oncology. Indeed, the high mortality and morbidity is due to diagnosis of the disease well after it has spread. MtDNA may offer an advantage over current techniques. Suzuki et al. scored D-loop mutations in 12 SCLC and 16 NSCLC matched B-lymphoblastoid cells lines [51]. In addition, a subset of the C_n was sequenced in 55 resected NSCLC and corresponding non-malignant lungs. Mutations were observed in 17 of the 28 cell lines (61 per cent; eight of 12 SCLC and nine of 16 NSCLC). Moreover, 95 per cent of the SNPs occurred in the hypervariable regions. In addition, single base substitutions were more frequent in the D-loop if the C_n was affected by an insertion or a deletion. For this reason, only the C_n was sequenced in the 55 resected samples. Within this group, 11 (20 per cent) had changes. Likewise, in an earlier study, Fliss et al. found a 43 per cent mutation rate in six of 14 lung cancer samples when sequencing the entire genome and D-loop only from selected samples [22]. Further work may identify sputum as a reliable source of mtDNA for monitoring lung neoplasia.

There is a pressing need to focus on the treatment, and therefore the early identification and subsequent monitoring, of pre-cancerous lesions,[1] and the analyses of changes in the mitochondrial genome, associated with neoplasia, holds promise in fulfilling this need. Here we have reviewed five specific types of cancer which have tissue, or biofluids, from which mtDNA can be extracted and analysed from an early detection perspective. Although promising, the early results described here await further work and validation. There are many important questions yet to be addressed: such as the relationship between mtDNA and the actual disease; are mutations causative or merely a reflection of nuclear instability? And, are these processes independent events? Alterations in the non-coding D-loop suggest genome instability; however, as studies focus more on the coding regions of the mitochondrial genome, particularly in the case of nonsynonymous mutations in the genes contributing products to the electron transport process, metabolic implications are evident. Moreover, mutations in mitochondrial transfer RNAs indicate the possibility of a global mitochondrial translational shut down. Importantly, the wide range in the number and location of mitochondrial alterations in patients, within and between studies addressing the same malignancies, indicates the need for a coordinated approach among researchers. Finally, the interplay between nuclear and mitochondrial genes requires careful investigation and may hold the final understanding of the mitochondrial role in tumourigenesis [52].